The Perfect Steak

Once upon a time there was a gal who didn’t know how to grill. It wasn’t that she wasn’t a good cook or skilled in the kitchen. It wasn’t even that she didn’t love food cooked on the grill. It was just that, well, growing up, her Dad had always done all of the grilling.

Then Chef Bobby of the Big Green Egg came riding in on his Chevy Pickup and made plans to change all of that. Not only was he going to teach the mom to grill, but he was also going to teach her how to cook the perfect steak…

Stay tuned for a happy ending, and a great recipe.

Alright, enough of fairy tales, lets get down to some good old Steak cookin’!

Folks, meet “Eggy”, The Big Green Egg. My Katy Rose named him and this is a photo of his arrival into the Jordan family, via the specialized attachment on Chef Bobby Cresap’s truck. Bobby is the executive Chef for the Big Green Egg and he was kind enough to come over and show me the ropes.

He was very patient and thorough in his teachings and it was great to get instructions from a pro such as him. It was actually quite an honor. I listened, I took mental notes…

And I ate every blessed thing that beloved man cooked. His food is divine.

These are Chef Bobby’s appetizers and my stomach is growling right now thinking about them. He took large mushrooms, removed the stems, and stuffed them with sausage before cooking them on the grill. They were to die for!

He made the recipe I’m bringing you today for the Perfect steak at my home and I have to tell you, it was the most delicious steak I’ve ever tasted in my entire life. I watched him go through every single step so I could show you how we did this, too.

So after all of this one on one instruction in how to grill, when it came time for me to recreate these steaks for myself, I did exactly what you’d expect me to…

Called in my dad :)

Meet Bill Davis. Retired from the Huntsville Police Department so he can just sit around and wait on me to call him and tell him we need steak.

~grins~

Daddy always did the grilling growing up and you know what folks say about things not being broke...

So let me show you how we make these perfect steaks.

You’ll need: Kosher salt, white pepper, black pepper, and cayenne pepper.

White pepper may be something you’ve never heard of but it’s easy to find in the spice section at pretty much any grocery store. I got mine at Krogers.

You’ll also need steaks. Chef Bobby recommends Rib Eyes, 1-1/2 to 2 inches thick.

It can be a bit of a quest finding (and affording) steaks that thick. These are a little over an inch thick and were pretty expensive, but still a LOT cheaper than all six of us going out to eat. Folks tell me that Sam’s Club has the best deals on them and if you have any hints or tips on where to find the best prices on steaks please feel free to leave them in the comments section below.

Place all of your dry ingredients in a shallow dish, like the pie plate I’m using here.

Stir them all together.

Press each steak into the mixture on both sides.

Like this.

You can do this before you’re ready to cook them and then just put them back in the refrigerator for a few hours, or you can do it right before cooking.

Chef Bobby says “It is perfectly acceptable to season your steaks well in advance of cooking them. The salt will pull some of the moisture from the surface of the meat. The moisture mixes with the salt and forms a brine which will pull the flavor into the steak by osmosis. When the meat and brine are in osmosis the seasoning will travel easily back and forth with the muscle tissues. So it really is hard to dry out the steak by seasoning early.”

Now lets get that grill going full steam ahead! Bobby says you want the temperature to be around 600.

Of course, you can use this same rub recipe on your steaks and cook it on whatever grill you happen to have at your house and it will even work in a cast iron skillet in your oven, too! Okay, so I just now realized that I need to do a whole other post on that method so I’ll get to work on it..

Place steaks on hot grill.

Cook two minutes.

Flip and cook two more minutes.

Flip again and close top to grill and cook two minutes more to have them at medium rare. Since we tend to be medium well people, we cook ours just a little bit longer.

This is my Mama and Daddy, enjoying their perfect steaks, salad with Vidalia Honey Viniagrette, and loaded baked potatoes.

And this is my kids and nephew Lane, enjoying their grandparents.

The Perfect Steak

The Perfect Steak

Ingredients

  • 4 Ribeye Steaks - 1-1/2 to 2 inches thick
  • 1/4 Cup Kosher Salt
  • 2 Teaspoons Black Pepper
  • 1/2 Teaspoon White Pepper
  • 1/4 Teaspoon Cayenne

Instructions

  1. Mix all of the dry ingredients together. Cover the tops and bottoms of the steak with the rub. You do not have to use all of the rub.
  2. Set the EGG® up for direct cooking and stabilize the temperature at 650° Cook the steaks for 2 minutes, flip them and cook for 2 more minutes, flip them one more time and close all of the vents on the EGG. Cook for 2 more minutes for mid rare and longer for more doneness.
  3. *You can easily use this same rub and cook the steaks on your own grill no matter what type it is, and they'll still be delicious. ~Recipe from Chef Bobby Cresap of The Big Green Egg
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin
http://www.southernplate.com/2011/03/the-perfect-steak.html

For more information on the Big Green Egg, chck out their website or chat with other EggHeads on their Facebook Page, or their extensive forums,which also provide a great source of support and answers to any questions you may have!


If you have any special grilling recipes you’d like to share, please feel free to do so in the comments below. If you just wanna drop a “Hidy” that’s fine, too! Chat, have a good time, and make yourself at home because we sure are glad you’re here!


Life is all about how you look at it. Is the glass half empty or half full? To me, if there is even a little something in my ‘life’ glass, then I am going to drink it up and consider myself blessed that I got a drop of it!

Submitted by Christy Day (thank you Christy!). To submit your quote or read hundreds more, please click here.

Free Holiday Recipes!

thanksgiving-collage

Looking for recipes to make your Holiday meals more special?

Click here to visit my Holiday Menu Bonanza Post with photos and links to *70* recipes! 

Enjoy This Post? Never Miss Another!

Subscribe to Christy's email list and receive all her new posts directly in your inbox

Comments

  1. Vickie says

    They looks so good! I haven’t learned to grill either. My dad always did it when I was a kid, and now my hubby does it, so no reason to fix something when it’s not broken! tee hee hee!
    We always gets our steaks at Kroger when they are on sale Like this week they are on sale for 4.00 a lb. Of course we bought some too! :) Hope you’ve had a great weekend! God Bless!

    • Jaime says

      Ok. I have loved every recipe that I have made from your cookbook and website with the exception of this one. We used your rub on some porterhouse steaks last night and they were inedible. WAY TOO MUCH SALT! We tried scraping it off and that didn’t work. To salvage them we had to rinse them off. It makes me cringe just thinking of it. My hubby makes wonderful steaks and was heartbroken when they came out like this.

  2. Theresa says

    I LOVE my Big Green Egg!!! I am so happy you had the opportunity to get a lesson on it as there is a bit of a learning curve. It is soooo unlike a regular grill. Many happy years egging away!! Hope to see you on the BGE forum!!!

    Theresa

  3. DebbyC says

    I used sirloin [had 2 thawed and cooked both] last night – and it was too spicey – probably could have cut the red and white pepper in half for us and we like spicey. I did leave the steak in the fridge for several hours, so that may have contributed….or since sirloin has less fat, it didn’t get cooked off as much – but the steak was so tender and juicy! Not to go to waste tho! – it will become lunch on a salad, cooked up with smushed/fried crispy tator tots, and some eggs scrambled in for breakfast tacos and probably a steak carbonara or fettucini.

  4. Cindy says

    I tell my husband he is a Big Green Egg snob–all he talks about with his buddies is how much better steak, fish, ribs–anything is on the BGE. I don’t have a clue how to use it but that’s the way I like it. Since the rest of our dining experiences are my responsibility he can keep up with the grilling.
    This looks like an excellent rub and I’ll try it the next time my husband decides to cook on the BGE. We’re addicted to added carmelized onions whenever we have steak. I think they would go well with this steak as well.

  5. Leroy Wion says

    Hi Christy! I got hungry just reading about the steaks on the grill. I enjoy grilling very much. One of my best meats for grilling is turkey thighs. I cut the bone out and then “butterfly” cut the thickest part of the thigh. I usually only use salt, pepper and Lowry’s seasoned salt for cooking my meat. Place the thighs on the grill, skin side down, season the meat side. Grill until golden brown, flip and season the skin side. Continue cooking until almost done. Then add your favorite BBQ sauce; basting both side until done. Very tasty. Sort of tastes like pork. I am a retired minister and enjoy experimenting with new ideas. Like reading your posts-Keep up the good work! God Bless!

  6. Barbara Anne says

    Christy – I don’t think my hubby is gonna let me visit your blog any more…. It costs him too much! My 1 1/2 year old gas grill died in December and I was promised a new one this Spring. Saw this post on Monday, found a dealer in my town and cooked with my new Egg today (Saturday)!! Told hubby happy birthday (today) but it’s really all for me. I love to grill and smoke my food and this baby can withstand the frigid temps of Michigan winters. Our steaks today were the best I’ve ever made and I’ve made some pretty darn good ones in the past. I think this whole week’s menu is revolving around that Egg. So excited to have discovered the Big Green Egg! THANK YOU.

  7. says

    We have the mini Green Egg since it is just my husband and I – and we LOVE it. He does all the grilling. We watch for sales for whole tenderloin. When we find it on sale for about $8.99/lb., we buy one, and have them to cut it into 1 1/2 inch thickness. We wrap each filet individually and freeze. We have enough steak to last us a couple of months. By doing it this way, we have filets for at least six meals (for 2) for about the cost of one dinner (for both of us) at a steakhouse. And they always are cooked to perfection.

  8. Larry says

    Christy…Here’s the recipe that we use inside.
    • Choose and season the steaks preferably 1 1/2 – 2 inches thick
    • Heat your oven to 425 degrees
    • Put enough oil in a cast iron skillet to just cover the bottom.
    • Heat the skillet until the oil begins to smoke.
    • Put steaks in the skillet and cook for 5 minutes. Do not touch the steaks.
    • After 5 minutes, turn the steaks and place the skillet in the oven.
    • Cooking in oven for 5 min = Rare; 7 min = medium; 9 min = well done
    • Remove from oven and let set for 10 minutes before serving.
    • Note: if steaks are thinner than 1 ½-2 inches cooking time must be adjusted.

  9. Mary says

    Christie! I loved how you give us step-by-step instructions on your recipes with pictures! Wonderful! It snowed last night here in CO, but we are expecting temps in the 70′s tomorrow! That’s crazy CO weather for you! I am going to marinate some chicken breasts in your marinade and season some ribeyes from this posting and grill away tomorrow!! Cannot wait! For those who thought the seasoning was too salty, spicy etc…next time just check the seasoning with a bit on your finger and “lightly” season until you know whether or not you will like the flavors! Shouldn’t be giving a recipe thumbs down if you don’t use common sense in these things. Have a wonderful day! God Bless!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *