Frozen Banana Pudding


If you’re on Facebook of Pinterest and could use one of those buttons above to share this with your friends, I’d surely appreciate it!

Oh Banana pudding. The recipe that has sustained many a Southerner through long journeys away from home just by sheer memory of the taste. The recipe that has had songs written about it, poems penned in honor of it (okay so I haven’t seen one but I’ll write one soon just to cover all bases), and the recipe that launched Southern Plate. I was a stay at home mom with a four year old daughter and a nine year old son. I had a home ec degree hanging on my wall gathering dust and a desire to write. So I started a little blog. It was on one of this free sites that no longer exists today. I’d write about what books I’d read, things we’d done with the kids, and sometimes I’d just go on there and write little stories about my life or the thoughts in my head.

Then, one day I realized that a friend of mine had never had homemade banana pudding. ~shudders~ I know, I know! I had to remedy that situation! The problem was that she didn’t know how to cook and you can’t just hand someone a recipe for homemade banana pudding and expect them to make it with no knowledge of cooking. So I decided to photograph step by step how to make it, and have fun goofing off a bit in the direciotns to boot (I don’t do “serious” very well). I posted that and the free blog host featured it on their homepage.

Now THAT got me excited! So the next day I posted Mama’s mandarin orange cake. They featured THAT on their homepage, too! The third day (I was on a roll) I posted how to make fried green tomatoes and that made the headline, right next to a picture and story about Llamas! I called Mama and said “Mama, I am as famous as the llamas!”. That afternoon I called my husband and said “I bet if I got my own domain I could get four or five hundred readers.” It seemed like a lofty goal but I wanted to try to impress him with my expectations of success :).

That day Mama and I played around with words, making lists of different Southern terms and putting them together and when my husband got home we bought and began setting it up for my blog.

The rest of the story is ….Probably a post for another day. So many twist and turns, filled with divine intervention in the past almost four years that it could easily become a book itself. Eventually though, I’m gonna have to tell you the story about how my Mama and Grandmama got more excited over a free box of Little Debbie cakes than they did over a big time New York book deal. I love their priorities…

ANYWHO, today I’m bringing you a frozen treat for grown ups :) While the kids have their water popsicles and ice cream cones, we can have these little beauties. Homemade Banana Pudding freezes wonderfully in individual serving sizes and lets you have this decadent Southern classic anytime you want. They’re great to keep on hand for last minute guests  or the afternoon unwind. This recipe makes about 18, but you can also just make half of them and use the other half to make a small warm banana pudding for two :) .

If you love banana pudding – real, honest to goodness homemade banana pudding – you’ve just got to make these!

Here are our ingredients. I normally take the photos on my kitchen counter or in the diner but it’s summer and ingredients get tired of posing for the same old photograph. Being the considerate photographer that I am, I took them outside and let them play with sidewalk chalk a bit. As you can see, they liked this photograph much better.

You’ll need: Vanilla Wafers, sugar, milk, eggs, flour, vanilla, a little salt, bananas, cupcake papers, and whipped topping.

Some other people had fun, too.

Y’all say hi to Jenny and Katy Rose


Place all of your ingredients in a medium sauce pot. As always, actual recipe is at the bottom of this post.

This is one of my gorgemous Calphalon pots that I ended up with as a reward for making it through TSA while wielding a skillet in the Charleston Airport. You can read about that by checking out this old giveaway post. The giveaway is closed but the story of how I ended up with this pot still resides there.

Mix that up a bit with a whisk.

There are a few kitchen tools that I like to have multiples of. Whisks and tongs are at the top of my list. I probably have five or six whisks and at least as many pairs of tongs. Big slanted wooden spoons also rank pretty high and I wish I had a bevy of pie servers because I seem to be forever cursed with taking pie places and losing a server somewhere in the deal – so I’m always looking to buy more of those. As many as I’ve bought throughout the years, I still have the hardest time finding one when I need it – but lots of places I’ve been have found pie servers in my wake!

That’s me. I’m a giver :)

Cook your pudding over medium heat, whisking or stirring constantly, until it is thickened, about fifteen minutes.

I know this takes commitment but hang in there because if anything is worth the time, Homemade Banana Pudding is!

I let mine cook all the way through and remove it once just thick. You can cook yours longer to get it thicker if you like but I like a thinner pudding to soak down into my wafers really good. It also continues to thicken after you remove it from the heat.

Once it’s done cooking, stir in your vanilla. I usually forget this step so just do as I say, not do as I do. 

It would be best if you stirred your vanilla in good before taking a photograph so that folks looking at said photograph don’t cock their heads and squint trying to figure out what those dark circles are….but roll with what ya got.

Pour banana pudding into a bowl or batter bowl (which is a bowl with a spout and a handle to make pouring easier) and place in the refrigerator until slightly cooled.

Line a muffin tin with muffin papers and place a few slices of banana in each cup. I do about four slices each.

NOTE: THIS WILL MAKE about 18, but I’m only making twelve here.

I took the rest and layered little banana puddings in cups for the three people skulking about watching me do this post.

Again, I’m a giver – in a family of skulkers no less! ~gasp~

Pour a little bit of pudding into each cup.

Like so :)

Place four Nilla Wafers in each one, around the sides so that the banana slices help hold them in place.

Add a dollop of cool whip on top of each ones and spread it touch the nilla wafers.

This is an important step because the top of the banana pudding crystalizes a bit as it freezes so this will help them stay all prettified. :) 

Freeze in the muffin tin.

Once frozen, stick a butter knife down between the muffin paper and the tin and it should pop right out. Place all frozen puddings into a zipper seal freezer bag and return to freezer until you get a hankering for one.


(The sooner, the better!)

Frozen Banana Pudding
  • ½ Cup Sugar (or splenda)
  • ⅓ Cup Flour
  • 3 eggs
  • 2 Cups milk
  • 1 box Nilla Wafers
  • 5 bananas
  • ½ teaspoon Vanilla
  • dash salt
  • Muffin papers
  • 8 ounces Cool Whip, thawed
  1. In sauce pot (or double boiler) on medium low heat, place sugar, flour, eggs, and milk. Normally we separate our eggs but since we're not making a meringue we're going to just use the entire egg here. Stir well with wire whisk.
  2. Allow to cook, stirring constantly to prevent scorching, until thickened - about fifteen minutes.
  3. Add in vanilla and stir.
  4. Pour into heat proof batter bowl or mixing bowl and cover with plastic wrap. Place in fridge just until cooled, about thirty minutes.
  5. Place 18 cupcake papers into two - 12 cup muffin tins with cupcake papers. Place about four slices of banana in each cup.
  6. Pour a small amount of pudding over bananas in each cup, just enough to fill it ½ to ¾ full.
  7. Place four nilla wafers down into the pudding cups on the sides, keeping the banana slices in the center to help hold them up.
  8. Add a dollop of whipped cream to the center of each one and spread until it touches the wafers.
  9. Place muffin tins into freezer for a few hours, until completely frozen. Insert a knife into the muffin tin between the tin and the paper to pop it loose.
  10. Put frozen puddings in freezer bag or airtight container and return to freezer until ready to serve.

I’d LOVE to hear back from you in the comments below! 

You must not lose faith in humanity.

Humanity is an ocean;

if a few drops of the ocean are dirty, the ocean does not become dirty.




Enjoy This Post? Never Miss Another!

Subscribe to Christy's email list and receive all her new posts directly in your inbox


  1. Kay says

    I made these and took to church this past Sunday. We have several gluten intolerant folks at our church and wondered if this could be made with corn starch instead of flour? Also once they thaw they aren’t good. My husband loved them.

  2. Harriet says

    These are freezing at my house right now. I bet they would be good to make bite sized in mini muffin tins with one vanilla wafer in the bottom like a crust instead of four placed into the sides.

    • says

      Hey Becky! I would love to but I’m afraid I’m just not able at this time. However, weight watchers does offer an online calculator where you can input a recipe and get all of that information. It can be awfully handy!

  3. Cheryl says

    I thought these looked delicious and so I made them yesterday. My question is, are you suppose to eat them frozen or let them thaw out a little, with a spoon or your fingers? I need help figuring this out. I only made 12 and had the rest of the pudding over strawberries and it tasted great. I know for sure that I have a recipe for home made pudding. I didn’t know it was so easy to make.

  4. Carol Jameson says

    Hi Christy, your favorite Kitchen Designer here. I think these would be AMAZING to serve at a home builders party I’m throwing. Quick question, how long do I need to set them out so they will be ready to eat? 40 Contractors can be scary if their banana pudding isn’t perfect!

  5. Fran says

    What if you didn’t eat it frozen? Would it remain pretty or would condensation ruin cupcake liners? Would bananas turn black? What if they were frozen in plastic champagne cups, could they then be thawed out?

  6. Kat says

    I’m going to make these for my parents. Mom doesn’t get around like she used to and Dad loves your nanner pudding recipe (won me $500 at Christmas one year). They’ll have nanner pudding whenever they want. :)

  7. says

    Electronic cigarette is the recent invention that brings the new
    faces of cigarettes. The primary described use of e cigarettes is that they are a more protected alternative to conventional cigarettes, and
    secondly, they are a lot in control aid. If you liked this article and
    would like to recieve more unique free and up to date information for you site or blog please contact electroniccigarette-starterkit.

  8. sharon says

    I am gluten free and plan to make the pudding with tapioca starch (or cornstarch). Then I’ll use a gf cookie in the cupcake liner, add the banana slices, add pudding – and top it off with another gf cookie. A banana pudding sandwich… :-)

  9. Judy says

    I have a hard time enjoying cool whip. Too many family reunions since the 1970’s with cool whip desserts, I think. Will the recipe work as well with whipped cream or the “banana pudding best fit merangue, please?

  10. kayla says

    I need to 200 of these for a wedding. How far in advance can I make them? Could I make them 4 days ahead? then keep them frozen until a few minutes before serving?

    thank you.

  11. Pamela says

    Hey, need to change the subject for a bit. Does anyone remember summer (yellow) squash pudding? Sweet with meringue? Do any of ya’ll have the recipe? Thank you so much and love this banana pudding by the way!

  12. Lori D says

    Do you think it could be made with egg substitute??? Trying to really lower fat, calories & sugar, so I’m wondering if it would do OK? And the bananas won’t turn brown??? :)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *