If you have a copy of my third cookbook, Sweetness, this pie recipe is on page 142.
This is the pie I talked about in my Facebook Live this past weekend. The pie that brought tears to my eyes when I took that first bite…
The ingredients are simple and ones that could be found in kitchens of yesteryear. Raisins, Sweetened Coconut, vanilla, Butter, Sugar, Chopped pecans, and eggs.
Place your sugar and butter in a large mixing bowl and beat with an electric mixer until light and fluffy.
Add eggs, beat again.
Add all other ingredients and stir with a large spoon until well incorporated.
I like to put my pie on a baking sheet, always do, no matter what kind of pie. It just makes it easier to get in and out of the oven that way. Bake at 350 for 35-40 minutes, or until it’s set in the center and doesn’t jiggle when you wiggle it. Don’t worry if you jiggle when you wiggle because we aren’t here to judge.
Now at this point, you can serve it but it won’t completely set until it is chilled so I cover and refrigerate it a couple of hours.
Serve chilled.
Oh mercy. This pie. This old fashioned, simple, incredibly delicious pie…it wants you to take a bite.
Look at it, staring longingly at your fork. Won’t you welcome it into your home today?
If Grandmama were here, she would say you need to. 🙂
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup raisins
- 1 cup boiling water
- 1/2 cup butter at room temp (unsalted or salted, whatever you have)
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 2 large eggs
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 1/2 cup pecans chopped
- 1/2 cup sweetened shredded coconut
- 9 inch pie crust unbaked (you don't need deep dish, regular is fine)
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350. Place raisins in a small bowl and cover with boiling water, set aside for five minutes and then drain.
- Cream together the butter and sugar in a large mixing bowl with an electric mixer until fluffy. Add eggs and beat again until well incorporated, 1-2 minutes.
- Add all other ingredients and stir by hand until well incorporated. Pour into pie shell.
- Bake 35-40 minutes, or until set in the center. Allow to cool completely and then cover and refrigerate several hours before serving.
Instead of saying “Lord, I don’t know how I’m going to do this.”
say,
“Lord, I can’t wait to see how you do this!”
Yum 
It’s a yummy pie! Just realized has similar ingredients as Japanese fruitcake– another oldie but goodie!
Exactly what I was thinking!
I was thinking that,too, as soon as I saw the ingredients. Pretty sure that’s the reason for the name.
So easy to make! I love it ❤️❤️
I am so glad you like it Cassandra!!! It is one of my favorites!
Our “exotic” old recipes 😉 Hope you’re having a good day, Susan!
How about Rice and Gravy Cake for exotic? It’s really Bisquick Velvet Crumb Cake, but my Granddaddy always thought it looked like rice and gravy, so the name stuck! This pie looks good even with raisins! Think I’ll be trying it soon.
Isn’t it funny how each family has their own names for things? love it!!!
Our family calls your Grandmama’s Chocolate Chess pie (which is my adult kids absolute favorite pie!) “funeral” pie! I am a huge pie fan and when I was younger and my girls were still living at home, I would regularly bake pies for funeral luncheons and the girls swear that’s the only time I baked it. Now I KNOW that’s not true but its what they tell me and laugh about every time I bake it now. But funny, family unique names stick!
My oldest son had moved out by the time I was making the chess so when they moved back to our hometown and his sisters started talking about funeral pie, he was quite skeptical – but then he tasted it! And he’s now converted!!
Thanks for the recipes!
My mom made this and I loved it. Took me a while to find it in her church and club recipes book she entered. She passed and was not in her recipe box. I always thought it would win more contests or requests if she renamed it
Fancy Pecan Pie. Instead of the Japanese Pie name?
There is one thing missing from the recipe that is considered the “secret ingredient.” It needs 1 Tablespoon of white distilled vinegar. I don’t know why, exactly, but try adding it and I promise it will be over-the-moon good. Just trust me; I’ve made it both ways.
Yes, Dale, my old tried & true recipe for this pie that was cut out of the newspaper in 1971, calls for one tablespoon of vinegar. I’ve never made this for anyone who didn’t like it. Even raisin haters. 🙂
This is also known as Osgood pie in other circles.
I don’t like vinegar, but I ve heard of a vinegar pie. What is the difference when you add it to this recipe? Coz I need convincing, lol
Thank you so much for letting me know Carol!!!
Maybe is was called Japanese because back then we associated everything coconut with the Pacific, and the Pacific brought memories of the Japanese war.
Great thinking Mary!!!
This looks amazing. Thank you for sharing it. I am not much of a baker but will give this a try! I got such a laugh about your comment about it not actually being Japanese and please don’t comment on the name!
heehee, and just wait, they’ll show up eventually 🙂 I hope you enjoy the pie!
My mother has making this pie for years. Only one differ is we use dates !!! Now, I’m the who makes it. I believe we had a teaspoon of white vinegar, too. Cindy from Harvest, Al.
Ohh, I might have to try it with dates!! Thanks for sharing!!
My Mummo used to make date bars and I haven’t been able to find her recipe anywhere (so it’s probably long-gone). I think this pie using the dates might come darned close. Thank you, so very much, for interjecting the date idea. Now I might just get tears in my old eyes, too!
Hey Melissa! I haven’t seen you around in ages. Good to hear from you again and hope all is well!
My mom used to make a Japanese Fruit Cake, sort of reminds me of it, except the cake had pineapple.
I found this info on a blog called Ivory Spring. It said the recipe dates back to colonial days. It also said…It is called “Japanese” because of the coconut flakes, and way back when, it was thought that coconuts came from Japan. It was purported that Martha Washington had it made for George Washington’s birthday one year.
Oh my goodness! Well now that makes sense – and is very interesting! Thank you!
P.S. George had good taste 🙂
My minister’s wife shared this yummy recipe with me years ago. Her recipe also included dates. Either way it’s delicious. Thanks for sharing it.
Sounds wonderful! Thank you! I have been thrilled to find that this pie is a heritage gem for everyone else, too!
I’ve made it using dried cherries instead of raisins and my family LOVED it!
I bet that was good!! So glad to hear it was a hit!!
I will try the dried cherries. I don’t care for raisins. Thanks for the hint!
I just wanted to say that I’m one that will leave out coconut, but it is a necessity. I’m allergic to it. Makes me itch from head to toe. So if anyone has suggestions to replace it, I’m all ears!!
Thank you very much, you are great
Sounds sorta like an Osgood Pie, except that one does not have coconut in it. I LOVE that one, so am sure I will enjoy this one too. Thanks for sharing!
I hope you get the chance to try it soon Loretta!!!
Made me think of mama… She loved to make this Japanese pie! Miss her so much! 🙂
🙂 enjoy a piece for her and cherish the memories it brings back!!!
I have to make this…………….I have another Japanese Fruit Pie recipe but it is different from this and I never made it…………….this one I will try. Thank you.
I hope you enjoy it Joanne!!!
I have made this pie many times. I have it in a community cookbook. It is so good. I hope folks will give it a try. Easy to make, and always a hit. All the ingredients/flavors blend together so nicely! I’ll have another price of pie!
Dear Christy,
I just wanted you to know that I think you are wonderful! I love your cute sayings and your down home humor. I absolutely love your recipes! I have made many of them. Thank you for all that you do. You are a delight!!!
From a loyal fan,
Diana
Thank you so much Diana!!! You just made my day. I appreciate all of your support more than you can imagine!!
I have made this pie many times. I have it in a community cookbook. It is so good. I hope folks will give it a try. Easy to make, and always a hit. All the ingredients/flavors blend together so nicely! I’ll have another price of pie! “Piece” of pie”. LOL
Thanks for sharing Karen, I hope people will try it as well!!! What is it called in your cookbook?
My grandmother made this pie! She added some crushed and well drained pineapple to hers! Maybe that’s where the “Japanese” connection was!
Perhaps so!! Good thinking!!
LOL You are so funny! And it is calling my name and I need it in my life right now, from the moment I saw the picture in my inbox! When I first saw the title I thought of the New Japanese Fruitcake, like the other comments. It is an old southern cake too, that is said to have been around for over 100 years and has nothing to do with Japan either. Your Grandmama’s pie does seem similar to an Osgood Pie, just with coconut. At first I thought it was a double crust pie, because of the way it looks on top. It looks so lovely and delicious. I will be making it this weekend. Thanks for sharing Christy.
I can’t wait to hear what you think Jayson!!
I made this pie yesterday and it is already half gone! It is absolutely delicious. Definitely a keeper, one I will make again and again. Thank you so much for the wonderful recipe Christy!
I make this pie but I add chocolate chips, coconut,pecans,and dried cranberries,it is great at Christmas parties.Debbie
Hee hee! I saw coconut and thought yum! THEN I saw raisins and said “Ew!” hee hee Guess who’s gonna double the coconut!! This girl! hee her
🙂 that works!
Christy, Us raisin haters are gettin
jealous of all the attention the coconut haters are gettin in your posts. Just so you know. FYI
lol
Dang. I’m sorry, I didn’t even think about folks hating raisins! I’ll make sure I address y’all in a more worthy manner in my next raisin recipe 😉
~hugs and grins~
I love coconut and raisins, unfortunately my family doesn’t, so if I made this I would have to eat the entire pie myself. Ugh! Wish I was around people who liked both so I could make it. Maybe I will try hand pies so I could eat one and freeze the rest.
My Grandmother called it a chess pie. She made a raisin one and a coconut one. When she passed away for some reason my two older aunts insisted I make them one every year near Christmas. One wanted the raisin and one wanted the coconut. Wish my Grandmother had thought to combine them like yours did. Would have been much easier. So wonderful to have all these old recipes. They were very inventive back in the day. Love your site.
They were inventive!! I hope you get to try the combination sometime soon, would love to hear what you think!!
This recipe is my mom’s “go to” pie when she needs a quick dessert to take some where. She makes sure she has the needed ingredients on hand. Never know when she’ll have make “THE” pie. It all gets gone, just an empty pie pan to throw away. Everyone loves this pie, and knows she usually will bring one.
I bet she is always the hit at pot-lucks, and well loved by everyone around her!!
Not a raisin fan, but I’ll make this pie and give it a shot! It certainly sounds amazing! (I may tweak it after that, but it still sounds yum-o!)
I hope you enjoy it!!
Christy,
First of all, I love your blog and wish you were my Southern daughter! Your pyrex collection is what drew my attention to your blog via some pyrex something or another. I’m so glad it did.
Is there a possibility that this pie was once called “depression pie?” Moons ago when I was first married and dinosaurs walked the earth, my Hubby and I were youth pastors at a small country church. There was a member there who made a pie and they called it depression pie. Looking at the list of ingredients, I think they might be the same but can’t say for sure; that was 41 years ago!
I’m going to try your recipe but was just wondering if you knew or if you had a recipe for a “depression pie.”
You know, a lot of recipes that ended up being easy to get ingredients for during the depression were later referred to as “depression” this or that, as a way of referencing when the recipe became popular or known to the family. We have several recipes with depression in the title for that very reason. I wonder if that is what happened here? I think it’s entirely possible. Hmm
I made this pie once. Years ago. And I swooned when I tasted it. I still remember it. Thanks for the recipe so I can make it again. It is heaven!
🙂 I am so glad to hear you had the same reaction!! I hope you get the chance to make it soon!!
Maybe Grandmama soaked the raisins in Sake to make it Japanese! Lol
Lol! Not this grandmama. Although if it had of come from another grandma that would have totally fit!
Just gotta ask how you got the crimping on the edge of the crust to look so incredibly perfect… mine comes out so lumpy and irregular! any tips? Thanks!
Well Lisa, my big secret is, I bought it that way 🙂 but I would encourage you not to even try to make your homemade pie crusts look perfect. Let homemade look homemade, it’s far more beautiful than store bought. 🙂
Girllllll, when I got to “Don’t worry if you jiggle when you wiggle because we aren’t here to judge.”…I LITERALLY CACKLED out loud!!! Too funny!! Definitely making this pie…simply because you don’t judge my jiggles!
🙂 I hope you love it as much as I do!!!
Oh the memories!!! I have my mother’s hand written recipe card for this pie and remember her making it almost weekly. It was a family favorite…I have made it in the years since she passed and still love it. Glad to see it is a favorite of many other families as well!
I vividly remember the first day I made Japanese Fruit Pie. It was a Sunday in 1972 and it was published in The News and Observer, a Raleigh NC paper. I cut the recipe out of the paper and made it that day. It is my favirite pie and I still have that small piece if paper I cut from the paper. Their recipe called for a teaspoon of vinegar. I have made it without the vinegar and its not as good. Also their recipe did not require you to soak the raisins. Brings back many memories. Thanks for sharing.
I have never heard of or tasted a Japanese Fruit pie but that is about to change. Odd thing about coconut. For decades I was against coconut and did not eat it or use it in my cooking . I have had a change of heart or taste as I now like it. Maybe I am just weird but I have noticed several taste changes as I age. Somethings I thought were delightful no longer entice me and things I did not consider are now fine. I have not yet conquered my distaste for fish!!!
Coconut fan here, especially toasted which is how I’ll make this pie. And, will use dried cherries as I’m not a raisin fan. Or, golden raisins.
Lately, I’ve been wondering how God is going to do a LOT of things…He has a plan!
This sounds like a must make, thanks!
PS, I love how you incorporated the vintage Pyrex images in the Sweetness book!
My Dad always talked about Raisin Pie but I never could find a recipe to make one for him. I wish he was still around to try this. I will have to make one in his memory!
Christy, you are such a blessing for all of us!
I’m so glad that you gave us fair warning up front, about the coconut! Nowdays, I don’t dare buy carrot cake or oatmeal cookies without carefully reading the ingredients, because folks are throwing that white shredded stuff into a formerly perfect dessert. LOL
I have been waiting to see the recipe for the pie you referred to on Sunday. It was worth the wait! It sounds like something I would like. I will definitely make this!
I’m at work at checking my email, shhh, don’t tell anybody! Saw your recipe and had to check it out. I have to say, the recipe has my attention because I love all the ingredients, but I just like the way you put the story and instructions out there. I was giggling…at work…and I’ll just say “it was Christy’s fault!” I appreciate you!