Candy Corn and Peanuts (Tastes Like a PayDay Bar)

Ever notice how candy corn and peanuts eaten together taste just like a PayDay candy bar? Stir the two together in a pretty bowl and you’ve got the easiest sweet and salty snack mix for a Halloween party, a fall get-together or a movie night, with no cooking at all.

A bowl of candy corn and peanuts that tastes like a PayDay candy bar

A Quick Look At The Recipe

  • Recipe Name: Candy Corn and Peanuts (Tastes Like a PayDay Bar)
  • Serves: 8 servings
  • Main Ingredients: candy corn, salted peanuts
  • Why You'll Love It: Candy corn and peanuts stirred together make a sweet and salty snack mix that tastes just like a PayDay candy bar. Two ingredients and about 2 minutes.

My Mama threw such a fit wanting me to share this one that I finally gave in, and around here a Southern fit is not something you ignore. It’s also a perfect recipe for little kids to make, since it takes so little for a child to feel proud of something they made all by themselves.

Why Candy Corn and Peanuts Taste Like a PayDay

A PayDay bar is salted peanuts pressed around a chewy, sweet center. Candy corn has that same buttery, honey-vanilla sweetness, so when you get a salty peanut and a piece of candy corn in the same bite, it tastes surprisingly close to the real thing.

Ingredients

Candy corn: Classic candy corn or the brown and orange autumn mix both work.

Peanuts: Use whatever kind you like. Salted dry roasted or cocktail peanuts give the best sweet and salty balance.

You’ll find the exact amounts in the recipe card below.

Helpful Tips

  • Start with equal parts and adjust to taste, adding more peanuts for salty or more candy corn for sweet.
  • Serve it in a pressed glass bowl or a mason jar to make it look extra festive.
  • Scoop it into small cellophane bags for class parties or neighbor gifts.

How to Make PayDay Candy Mix

1Add to a Bowl

Pour the candy corn and peanuts into a bowl.

2Stir and Serve

Stir to combine and serve right away, or store in an airtight container.

What to Serve It With

Set out a bowl on the Halloween party table next to butterscotch haystacks, sweet and salty fall snack mix and homemade caramel corn, or pair it with big chewy Halloween candy cookies. You’ll find plenty more ideas in our list of easy Halloween treats and desserts.

Candy Corn and Peanuts FAQs

What’s the best ratio of candy corn to peanuts?

Equal parts is a good place to start. Some folks like a little more peanuts so it’s not too sweet.

How long does it keep?

Stored in an airtight container at room temperature, it keeps for a couple of weeks.

What else can I add?

M&M’s, Reese’s Pieces or candy pumpkins all make it even more colorful.

Southern Plate Recipe

Candy Corn and Peanuts (Tastes Like a PayDay Bar)

Candy corn and peanuts stirred together make a sweet and salty snack mix that tastes just like a PayDay candy bar. Two ingredients and about 2 minutes.
Prep Time 2 minutes
Total Time 2 minutes
Servings 8 servings

Ingredients 

  • 2 cups candy corn
  • 2 cups salted peanuts dry roasted or cocktail peanuts

Instructions

  • Pour the candy corn and peanuts into a bowl.
  • Stir to combine and serve.

Notes

Ratio: Equal parts is a good starting point. Add more peanuts for saltier, more candy corn for sweeter.
Add-ins: M&M’s, Reese’s Pieces or candy pumpkins all work.
Storage: Keep in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 2 weeks.
Keyword: candy corn and peanuts, candy corn snack mix, halloween snack mix, payday candy mix, two ingredient snack
Tried this recipe?Mention @southernplate or tag #southernplate!

176 Comments

  1. Hi Christy,
    This candy would have been great for my nicotine fits I used to have. When I was trying to quit smoking I ate candy corn. You know they put sugar in cigarettes to get you addicted too. I would like to see the lotion recipe. (Us Moms have to stick together. LOL!) I really enjoy your site and can’t wait to try some of the recipes. By the way, the only thing I see missing in your breakfast meal is chocolate gravy. We have Christmas breakfast every year and try to make everything we can think of to eat for breakfast. It’s great and a lot of fun to hang out and visit with family and friends. Good luck on you site. Tell Your Mom I’m cheering for her. You catch more flies with honey than vinegar. Ha! See ya round! Cyngen

  2. I LOVE this idea! So good and so simple! I wonder if it would work as well with some of the “new” flavors, like caramel chocolate corn… I sure think I’ll be trying this!

  3. My mama in law keeps this stuff right in the four yer right up until november 1st when she busts out the fudge and divinity!

  4. hissy fits are a common fact of life at my house and things just get slammed and banged and no one really gets hurt to long as they stay out of my way! As for the candy recipe , I love paydays, reminds me of when I was a kid !! Have,nt tried recipe yet but movie night is coming so will give it a whirl. As for crock pot , had some one for 12 yrs of happy marriage, handels have broken off but still cooks, could use new one ! love this site and so glad I joined !!

  5. I have never tried this! I bet kids would love this! I also had never heard of all the different kinds of fits! Fun post!

  6. I am so glad that all of you are replying favorably to my Pay Day candy. I did keep after Christy to pass this recipe along to you. I told her that every recipe did not have to be a family heirloom recipe. Sometimes the easy recipes are some of the best. I also told her that she should pass along our recipe for the best hand cream (we use it all over our body). Her son, Brady, made it for Christmas gifts last year. It is really easy to make and loved by everyone that uses it. It smells really great too. Now I have figured out how to get Christy to post the recipes that I suggest. I’ll just suggest them as a comment and have everyone else throw a hissy fit until she does it! That way I don’t get in hot water for nagging her! I think I finally have this internet stuff figured out.
    There must be hope for us old folks afterall. I’ll think about it tomorrow and come up with another “suggestion” for something that you may want to see on her blog. Just check back periodically and if you like what I suggest, nag Christy until she does it. Mama

    1. Hey Christy, I would love to have the hand cream recipe and would hate for your Mama to have to have another hissy fit! Good hand cream really is expensive. Keep up the good work! Kathy

    2. Are you talking about the dollar store cream?
      2 (9 ounce) bottles of baby lotion
      2 (8 ounce) jars of vitamin e lotion and
      vaseline petroleum jelly
      This IS good stuff!!
      Mama, maybe YOU need to start a blog TOO! Love both of yall!

    3. Hi “Mama J” ~waves to you~
      Thanks for the suggestion so all us SP folks can get a laugh today and a great idea for candy dish contents. I have the ingredients on hand and am heading to the pantry in a minute to begin my quest to bring joy to my family soon.

      I am so looking forward to the honor of meeting you in Atlanta soon as I admire you and I just know you are as warm & wonderful as Christy tells me all the time. I hope we can spend a few minutes together and hear about your lovely home, the grandchildren and your travels w/ Christy’s Dad.
      See ya soon
      Terri

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe or Post Rating